MIDDLE BROTHER * MIDDLE BROTHER
(Partisan Records)
Brandishing the title of "supergroup" is enough pressure for even the most seasoned group of musicians, so when the fairly young trio of John J McCauley III (Deer Tick), Taylor Goldsmith (Dawes) and Matt Vasquez (Delta Spirit) announced their debut under the Middle Brother umbrella late last year, they had to know there'd be an instant light cast on them. Encompassing three of the more talented singer-songwriters of the recent modern-Americana boom, Middle Brother's debut is pleasantly effective.
McCauley's signature raspy twang helps kick off the album, giving us the kind of not-so-subtle storytelling experience we've already heard on the individual albums from the respective bandmates. Three songs in, "Thanks For Nothing" grants us the first real taste of Goldsmith's work on the record, a contemplative bummer of a tune that highlights the gorgeous rootsy crooning of the Dawes frontman. The title track (of the album and the band) oozes with a snotty, yet lovable vibe which will undoubtedly be a live highlight when the sum and their parts arrive at First Avenue for a March 14th showcase.
While we've been pitched a Middle Brother album, it's hard to deny that at times, it feels like the first half is the McCauley/Deer Tick show, with the influence of Dawes & Delta Spirit on the back burner. I can't help but think we've been shorted some of Goldsmith's booming choruses and Vasquez's unique arrangements. Vasquez's first noticeable contribution to the record comes 5 songs deep, in the somewhat forgettable "Theater." Luckily for us, this low point vanishes quickly as The Mats' "Portland" is given an interesting and intriguing twist and opens up the second half of the record to be a little more collaborative. "Wilderness" slows things down, as Goldsmith settles into a cozy, introspective balance with the 60s-rock influence of "Me Me Me" that immediately follows. It's hard to tell if "Someday" is an original or a Jay & The Americans cover, but it succeeds either way. "Blood & Guts" is an expansive version of the song originally crafted by the pre-Dawes Simon Dawes, showing Goldsmith's adaptability and progression as a singer-songwriter. The album closes with "Million Dollar Bill," one last attempt to showcase all three of the frontmen at once, which ultimately (and unfortunately) gets a little clunky.
Middle Brother won't get a Monsters of Folk kind of supergroup buzz, and that's probably a good thing. Their debut sounds nothing like one; for what it's worth, these guys could've been playing together for a decade and we wouldn't have heard anything different. Like Dawes' North Hills and Deer Tick's Black Dirt Sessions, the Middle Brother debut will probably be more appreciated after hearing the tracks played live, and that consensus will be reached in two short weeks.
Grade: B+